What are the Main Differences Between STD and LTD Benefits?

This post will discuss the differences between short-term disability ( STD ) benefits and long-term disability ( LTD ) benefits.


It is always important to review your benefits booklet and policy to know what coverages you are entitled to.

The Waiting Period

The waiting period for STD benefits is relatively short compared to LTD benefits and can be as short as 1 day or as long as 2 weeks. Short-term disability benefits are meant to provide almost immediate financial assistance when you become disabled, whereas LTD benefits could have a waiting period of anywhere from 119 days to 52 weeks.


Typically, if you have coverage for both STD and LTD benefits, LTD benefits would start at the end of the STD period, if you meet the definition of disability. In most cases, STD benefits are meant to cover the duration of the waiting period for long-term disability benefits.
​
If you do not have STD benefits as part of your compensation package, you can apply for EI Sickness Benefits to help you during the waiting period. These benefits are paid for 15 weeks.

How Long Benefits Are Paid For

Short-term disability benefits can only be paid for the amount of time set out in the policy. The duration of benefits can range from 15 to up to 52 weeks.


Long-term disability benefits can be paid for a much longer period of time, unless the policy specifies there is a maximum period (i.e. there are some policies that have a 2 year, 5 year, 10 year maximum, depending on the reason for disability if it is a private policy or depending on what the employer chose).

How Your Benefit is Calculated

Short-term disability benefits are calculated based on a percentage of your weekly earnings and this percentage can range from 50% to 100% of your earnings, depending on your policy.


Some policies use a tiered system where you receive a higher percentage of your salary for the first few weeks, and a lesser amount for the majority of the STD period, and other policies use the same calculation for the entire period.

Long-term disability benefits are calculated based on a percentage of your monthly earnings and the percentage can typically range from 35% to 70% of your monthly earnings, policy dependent. Depending on your employer, you may have the option to “top up” your benefit and receive a higher LTD benefit. For example, your employer may offer you a “core benefit” of 35% of your monthly earnings and then offer you the option of increasing your benefit if you choose to pay the monthly premiums for it. You may be able to increase your benefit to 60-70% for example.

​Some short-term disability policies may also have optional coverage to top up core benefits.

How Often Benefit Payments are Made

Short- term disability benefits are paid to you weekly, and long-term disability benefits are usually paid on a monthly basis. Some policies pay LTD benefits semi-monthly.

Who Pays the Benefit

Some employers choose to have their short-term disability policies set up as an “Administrative Services Only” (ASO) contract.


This means that the insurance company adjudicates the claim (processes the claim) while the employer pays the actual benefit, if benefits are approved. The insurer will tell the employer if benefits are approved and when they are denied (but does not provide the employer with your medical information).

Under a long-term disability policy, the insurer is typically the payor of benefits and the administrator of the policy. Under some policies, the employer pays the benefit and has an ASO arrangement.

The Definition of Disability

You should review the definitions section of your policy to find out how “total disability” is defined.

Each policy may be different, but in order to qualify for benefits, a person must meet the definition of totally disability. To qualify for short-term disability or long-term disability benefits, your insurance company needs evidence that you are “totally disabled”.

When you apply for STD benefits, the test for total disability is whether you can perform the duties of your “own occupation” (or a similar occupation, in some policies).

Under most group LTD policies, there are two definitions of disability, the “own occupation” and “any occupation” definition of disability. A person could also have a private LTD policy where the disability test is own occupation only.

A total disability means you are reasonably unable to carry out the normal functions of your usual job. It does not mean that you have to be completely physically unable to do any part of your job, but that your injury or illness is such that you are unable to perform the essential duties of your own occupation.

This is the definition your insurer will go by during the “own occupation” period of your disability. When the own occupation is over, you are considered totally disabled if you are unable to perform any occupation for which you are reasonably suited for or could become suited for.

Change of Definition

Short-term disability benefits are not subject to a change of definition and the test for disability stays the same. As noted, under most policies, the test is whether you are capable of performing your own occupation.

Long-term disability benefits are subject to a change of definition and most policies are subject to a change of definition after 2 years. This could mean two years after the initial onset of disability, or two years after the waiting period ends. Some policies may have a shorter or longer own occupation period.


As mentioned, the change of definition means that the disability “test” used by your insurer changes from whether you can perform your own occupation to whether or not you can perform any occupation that you are suited for by education, training or experience.


It is important to read your own policy to find out what tests are applicable, when they apply and how long they apply for.

How a Lawyer Helps

Policy wordings and the language used in correspondence from your insurance company can be difficult to understand. Receiving a denial letter during a stressful time can be overwhelming.


A disability lawyer can help you understand the terminology and why your claim was denied and how long you have to act on that denial. Your rights will be explained to you and you can determine if you want to proceed with a lawsuit. As well, once you retain a lawyer, you will no longer have the stress of speaking with your claims adjuster to provide updates or medical information.


Our lawyers have helped many clients successfully resolve their short-term and long-term disability claims. Contact our office for a free, no obligation initial consultation and remember, there are no bad questions!

Sleep Disorders and Long-Term Disability Claims

Sleep disorders can impact a person’s ability to work. Sleeping difficulties can be a symptom of depression, anxiety or other mood disorders or can be from a serious condition, like sleep apnea.


This blog will discuss:

  • The types of sleep disorders (with a focus on sleep apnea)
  • The complications of a sleep disorder
  • Sleep disorders and disability claims
  • Why your claim might be denied
  • What to do if your disability claim has been denied

What are sleep disorders? 

According to the National Sleep Foundation , there are various sleep disorders that fall under the following categories:

Abnormal sleep behaviour disorders

  • REM sleep behaviour disorder (acting out your dream)
  • Sleep talking
  • Sleep walking
  • Nightmares


Source: https://www.sleepfoundation.org/category/abnormal-sleep-behavior

Circadian rhythm sleep disorders

  • Shift work sleep disorder
  • Non-24 sleep wake disorder (abnormal sleep-wake rhythm – circadian clock is not in-sync with a 24-hour clock
  • Delayed phase sleep disorder (when preferred sleep time is delayed 3-6 hours, an inability to fall asleep at your preferred time and wake up at an acceptable time)


Source: https://www.sleepfoundation.org/category/circadian-rhythm-disorders

Excessive daytime sleepiness disorders

  • Narcolepsy (excessive sleepiness, falling asleep during normal activities, sleep paralysis, hallucinations, partial loss of muscle control)
  • Idiopathic hypersomnia (feeling sleepy even after getting a lot of sleep)


Source: https://www.sleepfoundation.org/category/excessive-daytime-sleepiness-disorders

Insomnia

  • Acute insomnia (i.e. brief episode of insomnia due to a stressful event)
  • Chronic insomnia (long-term difficulty sleeping, when someone has difficulty falling asleep/staying asleep for a minimum of 3 nights/week, for at least 3 months)
  • Comorbid insomnia (occurs with another condition (i.e. anxiety, depression or physical condition like arthritis)
  • Onset insomnia (difficulty falling asleep)
  • Maintenance insomnia (inability to stay asleep, disturbed sleep and inability to fall back asleep)


Source: https://www.sleepfoundation.org/insomnia/content/what-are-different-types-insomnia

Sleep related movement disorders

  • Restless legs syndrome (urges to move the legs while relaxing, worsens with age)
  • Periodic limb movements in sleep (uncontrollable repetitive movements in the lower limbs during sleep)
  • Sleep bruxism (clenching/grinding your teeth while sleeping)


Source: https://www.sleepfoundation.org/sleep-disorders-problems-list/sleep-movement-disorder-messing-your-slumber

Sleep related breathing disorders

Sleep apnea is considered to be a serious medical condition because it affects the way you breath when you’re sleeping. Sleep apnea occurs when your breathing is interrupted during sleep, i.e. your breathing starts and stops repeatedly.


There are 2 types of sleep apnea, obstructive sleep apnea and central sleep apnea. Obstructive sleep apnea is the most common type. There is also complex sleep apnea, which is when a person has both types of sleep apnea.

​

Obstructive sleep apnea occurs when the throat muscles relax and central sleep apnea occurs when your brain doesn’t send the proper signals to your muscles that control breathing.


Source: https://www.sleepfoundation.org/category/sleep-related-breathing-disorders

According to the Mayo Clinic, the most common signs of both types of sleep apnea include:

  • Loud snoring that disturbs the sleep of others, or yourself (more evident in obstructive sleep apnea)
  • Episodes of breathing cessation (pauses) that occur during sleep witnessed by another person
  • Hypersomnia (excessive daytime sleepiness), that causes you to fall asleep while working or even driving
  • Abrupt awakenings accompanied by shortness of breath (more indicative of central sleep apnea)
  • Dry mouth or sore throat upon wakening
  • Morning headache
  • Insomnia (difficulty staying asleep)
  • Problems with attention

Who is affected by sleep apnea?

Sleep apnea can affect anyone, including adults and children. Certain factors can make a person more likely to develop obstructive sleep apnea such as excess weight, neck circumference, narrowed airway, your gender (men are more likely to develop sleep apnea, but post- menopausal and overweight women have increased risk), your age (over 60) and family history and race. Other factors include nasal congestion, smoking and use of alcohol, sedatives or tranquilizers.


Risk factors for central sleep apnea include gender (males have a higher risk), age (people over 65), people with heart disorders and stroke or brain tumour.

Complications of sleep disorders 

Sleep apnea, for example, can affect a person’s ability to work as it affects a person’s quality of sleep and causes daytime sleepiness. This means that it can affect a person’s ability to drive and stay awake and alert at work. Staying alert at work is important for any job, but it is particularly important when it affects the safety of others, for example, jobs that involve operating heavy machinery or dangerous tools.


Sleep apnea is linked to a number of illnesses including high blood pressure and heart disease, increasing the risk of death.

​

If left untreated, sleep apnea can affect cognitive function like memory and decision making. A lack of sleep is known to lead to depressed mood and attention difficulties.

Sleep disorders and disability claims 

If you work in a safety-sensitive job, a job with heavy machinery or job that requires high levels of concentration and focus, having a sleep disorder like sleep apnea can be dangerous and severely impact your ability to work. Daytime sleepiness can mean you are not alert enough to perform your job duties or react in time for safety-sensitive or urgent situations. Or if your job is long-haul truck driving for example, you could be at risk for falling asleep at the wheel.


If you work in a sedentary position, but your job requires sustained focus and concentration, a sleep disorder can disrupt your ability to do just that. Your job may require you to make important decisions or do complex tasks or calculations and you may be noticing you are having difficulties due to your sleep difficulties.

​

When you make a claim for short-term or long-term disability, it is important to show the insurance company how your sleep apnea or difficulties sleeping impacts your day to day functioning and would affect your ability to perform your job. Be specific with your restrictions and limitations and symptoms.

Why might my claim be denied? 

Your claim for disability benefits could be denied at the outset of the claim, or at some point during the claim. Your insurer might find that while you are unable to perform the duties of your own job, you can perform the duties of another job.


For example, if you worked in a factory, where physical safety of yourself and others is a concern, your insurer might agree that you can’t return to this position, but may say you can work in a sedentary position like at a call centre or somewhere where safety is not an issue and a moderate amount of concentration is not required.


Other commons reason insurers deny claims is due to lack of medical evidence to support ongoing limitations and restrictions, that you are not under the care of an appropriate specialist and are not following the standard recommended treatment plan.

What should I do if my disability claim is denied?

Even if your claim has been denied, it is important that you continue to seek ongoing treatment and follow the treatment plan prescribed to you.

​

You should keep copies of all documents sent to you by the insurance company and keep records of all conversations you had with the insurance company as well. This information can be provided to your lawyer and help them understand what happened with your claim.


It is important to remember that you can fight the insurance company’s decision to deny your claim. When you consult a lawyer, you will be informed of your rights and obligations as an insured person and how long you have to sue your insurer (known as the limitation period). You should consult a lawyer as soon as possible to make sure you start a lawsuit against your insurance company before the limitation period is up.


Our firm offers a free initial consultation that can be arranged at a time that is convenient for you.

Invisible Illnesses and Long-Term Disability Claims

As long-term disability lawyers, we recognize there are various conditions that render a person unable to work. Many times, people are unable to work due to what are known as “invisible illnesses” or invisible disabilities.


This blog will discuss:

  • What is an invisible illness?
  • Types of invisible illnesses
  • Common reasons for claim denials
  • What to do if your claim is denied
sad woman on couch

What is an invisible illness?

Invisible illness is a term used for any medical condition that is not easily visible to others. Invisible illnesses include chronic physical conditions such as fibromyalgia and chronic pain conditions , headache disorders, Lyme disease, traumatic brain injuries as well as mental illnesses. These are conditions where the symptoms cannot be seen on diagnostic imaging on blood tests or easily tested.

Types of invisible illnesses

Invisible illnesses can be physical conditions or psychological conditions. What follows are some examples of conditions that are considered “invisible illnesses”.

Chronic Pain Disorders

Chronic pain can develop after an injury or surgery. Chronic pain is pain that persists for more than 6 months or when a person experiences pain after the time for usual healing has passed. Chronic pain interferes with various realms including sleep, concentration, memory and can affect functional abilities like the ability to perform self-care and hygiene, drive and attend work on a regular basis.


Chronic pain disorders include conditions such as fibromyalgia, myofascial pain syndrome, chronic fatigue syndrome and arthritic disorders. There are several types of arthritis including rheumatoid arthritis, connective tissue disease, lupus and osteoarthritis. It is also important to consider that chronic pain conditions can also involve a psychological component as chronic pain can potentially lead to the development of depression.

Mental Illnesses

Mental illnesses include anxiety and depressive disorder , bipolar and mood disorders and post-traumatic stress disorder .


The Canadian Mental Health Association (CMHA) defines mental illness as “the term used to refer to a variety of mental disorders that can be diagnosed. Mental disorders are health conditions that are characterized by alterations in thinking, mood or behaviour (or some combination thereof) associated with distress and/or impaired functioning”.


Some important facts to consider are:

  • 20% of Canadians will personally experience a mental illness in their lifetime
  • Approximately 8% of adults will experience major depression
  • Anxiety disorders affect 5% of Canadians
  • Approximately 1% of Canadians experience bipolar disorder
  • Schizophrenia affects 1% of Canadians


A mental illness can interfere with a person’s ability to sleep, ability to concentrate and focus, interfere with memory and the ability to attend work on a regular basis.

Traumatic Brain Injuries

According to Brain injury Canada , approximately 1.5 million Canadians live with an acquired brain injury and brain injury is the leading cause of disability and death for Canadians under the age of 40.


A traumatic brain injury can cause life-altering symptoms and challenges. Traumatic brain injuries can range from mild to severe.


A concussion is a type of mild traumatic brain injury and can also lead to prolonged symptoms such as ongoing headaches, memory difficulties and psychological difficulties if someone develops post-concussion syndrome.


A brain injury can result in various physical, cognitive and behavioural/emotional impairments which can be temporary or permanent.


Physical impairments include coordination and balance difficulties, chronic pain, fatigue, seizures and movement problems.


Sensory difficulties include vision or hearing difficulties. A brain injury can also cause difficulties with communication such as word-finding problems, impaired speech and emotional impairments such as depression, mood swings and anger. Cognitive difficulties can include memory loss, problems with attention and concentration, impaired judgement and social behavioural problems.

Headache Disorders

Headache disorders include migraines, tension-type headaches and cluster headaches.


A migraine disorder can be recurrent, life-long and is characterized by recurrent “attacks”.


According to the World Health Organization , headache disorders are among the most common disorders of the nervous system. It is estimated that 1.7-4% of the world’s adult population report experiencing headaches more than 15 days each month. In 2013, migraine was found to be the 6 th leading cause of disability worldwide.


A migraine can be accompanied by debilitating symptoms and can limit a person’s usual activities and ability to do both sedentary and physical work as it interferes with the ability to focus and is worsened by bright lights and loud noises. As well, the long-term efforts of coping with chronic headaches/migraine might lead to other illnesses such as anxiety and depression.

Lyme Disease

Lyme disease is an inflammatory infection spread through backlegged ticks (a.k.a. deer ticks). There are 3 stages of Lyme disease, including chronic Lyme disease which can last for months or even years.


There are over 100 known symptoms of Lyme disease and symptoms can affect your musculoskeletal system, mental capability, psychological wellbeing, digestive system, respiratory, circulatory and neurological symptoms.


Chronic Lyme disease is often mistaken for other illnesses which makes it difficult to diagnose and treat and prolonging the time it takes to diagnose. Lyme disease is also hard to diagnose because blood tests can show negative test results when the disease is actually present.


Lyme disease can be mistaken for other illnesses including fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome, colitis/Crohn’s disease, early ALS, encephalitis, lupus or inflammatory arthritis disorders, multiple sclerosis, psychiatric disorders, thyroid disease and sleep disorders.

Common reasons for claim denials

There are various reasons as to why an insurance company might deny a disability claim.

Lack of objective medical evidence

One of the reasons claims are often denied is due to a lack of objective medical evidence. This means that the insurance company did not feel there was enough medical information documented to support your disability and to show how your condition/illness restricts or limits you from performing your job duties or any job you could be qualified for.

Treatment is not appropriate

Another common reason is that you are not under the care of appropriate physicians/treatment provider or receiving appropriate treatment. You may be waiting on a referral to a specialist due to long wait times and may not have had specialized treatment yet when you are waiting for a diagnosis. For example, while you may be seeing your family physician or a social worker/psychotherapist regularly while waiting for a psychiatrist appointment, your insurance company might feel this is not sufficient treatment for a mental illness.

You have been able to work with your condition

Your claim might also have been declined because you demonstrated an ability to work in the past with your condition. Perhaps you have a chronic condition and had been working modified duties or hours at your job for some time but found you were unable to keep up with your duties. You may have had an exacerbation or worsening of symptoms but your insurance company might not understand how or why your condition currently prevents you from working.

You can perform some type of work

Your insurance company may be aware of your symptoms but may take the position that despite your symptoms and receiving treatment, you should be able to perform your job or some type of alternate employment. Your insurer might be of the opinion that you could still attend/seek treatment while working and decide to deny your application or discontinue benefits on that basis.

What to do if your claim is denied

We understand that experiencing a denial of benefits from your short-term or long-term disability insurer is stressful.

Report your symptoms

With an invisible illness or condition, one way to demonstrate how your condition impacts your life and functional abilities by reporting your symptoms to your family doctor and treating specialists/treatment providers. Be truthful with your treatment providers about how you are feeling and if and when you have changes to your symptoms/condition.

Keep attending treatment

When it comes to any type of disability claim, it is important to remember that even if your benefit has been denied, you should continue to seek treatment from your family physician, specialist (s) or rehabilitation clinic (physiotherapy, massage etc.) so you can document your symptoms and show you continue to comply with treatment recommendations.


If you are unable to work due to an invisible illness, you want to demonstrate that you are under the care of a physician/specialist and are following a recommended treatment plan. By regularly consulting with your treatment providers and physicians, you are documenting your symptoms and activity restrictions and these records are helpful for your claim.

Know your rights

If your claim for short-term or long-term disability benefits has been denied, you should contact an experienced disability lawyer as soon as possible to find out what your rights and obligations are as an insured person. Your lawyer can explain to you what your options are and how the legal process works.

Our lawyers have helped many clients whose claims for invisible illnesses have been denied. We offer a free consultation that can be conducted via phone or Zoom/Skype at a date and time that is convenient for you.

Seasonal Affective Disorder and LTD Claims: What you need to know

As long-term disability lawyers, we recognize that depression and other types of psychological illnesses such as bipolar disorder, schizophrenia and anxiety disorders can render a person unable to work as psychological symptoms can interfere with various aspects of a person’s life.


This blog post will examine:

  • What is seasonal affective disorder?
  • What are the symptoms?
  • Who is most affected by SAD?
  • SAD and COVID-19
  • How does it affect my ability to work?
  • Why would my claim be denied?

What is seasonal affective disorder?

In the late fall/winter months, there are fewer hours of sunshine per day. Some people experience what is known as seasonal affective disorder (SAD) which is a type of depression that is related to the change in seasons.


Typically SAD occurs in the fall and continues into the winter months but can occur in the spring and summer months.


Symptoms can start as mild and become more severe the further we get into the season.


​While the exact cause of SAD is unknown, it is felt that possible causes involve the reduced level of sunlight in the fall and winter as it disrupts the body’s internal clock (which controls sleep-wake patterns) and it disturbs the functions of neurotransmitters such as serotonin and dopamine. Serotonin is a neurotransmitter that affects mood.

What are the symptoms?

According to the Mayo Clinic , seasonal affective disorder is a subtype of major depression.


Symptoms of major depression can be a part of seasonal affective disorder and include:

  • Low energy
  • Loss of interest in activities
  • Feeling depressed most of the day, every day
  • Difficulties sleeping
  • Fluctuating appetite and weight
  • Agitation
  • Difficulty with concentration


There are also symptoms specific to winter-onset SAD and spring/summer SAD.


Symptoms specific to winter seasonal affective disorder include:

  • Irritability
  • Low energy/tiredness
  • Feelings of “heaviness”
  • Appetite changes
  • Weight gain


With seasonal affective disorder, the signs and symptoms tend to appear and disappear at the same time each year.

Who is most affected by SAD?

According to the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH), risk factors for developing seasonal affective disorder include:

  • Being female as women are more likely to be diagnosed with SAD
  • Living far north or far south of the equator
  • Being young; young people are more likely to develop SAD and the risk decreases with age
  • Having a family history of SAD or other forms of depression increases the risk


​Seasonal affective disorder affects people with mood disorders, in particular, bipolar disorder. Fall/Winter SAD can trigger depression and spring/summer can bring symptoms of mania or hypomania.

SAD and COVID-19

The COVID-19 pandemic has affected millions of people worldwide, physically and mentally.

Since the lockdowns and restrictions in Ontario, people may still be feeling an increased sense of isolation and further symptoms of depression and anxiety. This can be due to fear of leaving the home as a result of COVID-19 or because their job is still completely remote.

The pandemic has brought with it stress from lack of social interaction and isolation, fear for the health and safety of ourselves and our family/friends, and an overall sense of uncertainty. All of these things can negatively affect anyone’s mental health. This is especially true for people already living with depression and other mental health conditions.

Statistics Canada conducted a survey from February to May 2021 on COVID-19 and Mental Health.



The survey showed that:

  • 25% of Canadians aged 18 and older had symptoms of depression, anxiety or post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) in spring 2021
  • More adults aged 25 to 64 screened positive for at least one mood disorder. Among the age group 25 to 44
  • 83% of adults ages 18-24 experienced at least one negative health (mental or physical) impact due to COVID-19
  • 80% of adults 25-44 experienced at least one negative mental or physical health problem due to COVID-19
  • 70% of adults aged 45-64 had a mental health impact
  • 65% of adults over the age of 65 had at least one mental health impact
  • 77% of Canadians screened positive for at least one mental health disorder

With the need to physically distance and strict restrictions, plus the colder weather, the pandemic meant we had to stay inside more, which decreased exposure to natural sunlight. This is important for people who suffer from depression. Decreased exposure to sunlight can mean more severe symptoms for someone who typically experiences SAD and can also mean more people might have experience SAD over the last couple of years.

How does it affect my ability to work?

Psychological illnesses can affect a your ability to concentrate, interact with co-workers, your level of self-confidence, ability to multi-task, energy levels and ability to sleep amongst other things.


As mentioned, SAD is a type of depressive disorder. People may apply for short-term or long-term disability benefits as a result of their symptoms of depression as they interfere with many aspects of your life.


For example, if you work in a physical labour position like at a factory or construction site, you may find that your fatigue, low energy and difficulty concentrating interfere with the safety-sensitive aspects of your job.


If you work in an office-type position, you may find that your symptoms affect your ability to focus, concentrate, interact with others and therefore complete your duties.

Why would my claim be denied?

As depression is an “invisible illness”, insurance companies often deny claims for short-term and long-term disability benefits because you do not meet their definition of totally disabled for reasons such as:

  • There is not enough medical evidence to support you have been disabled for the entire waiting period and beyond
  • Lack of objective medical evidence to substantiate your absence from work
  • No medically supported restrictions and/or limitations
  • Your insurer believes you can perform modified duties or can participate in a gradual return to work program
  • Your insurer believes you can perform your own occupation while attending treatment
  • Your insurer believes you can perform an alternate occupation


If your claim has been denied for any reason, you should not hesitate to call our law firm for a free initial consultation. Our lawyers have helped many clients who are unable to work due to mental health reasons. We are offering virtual consultations and consultations by phone and can arrange for document signing through DocuSign for your convenience.

Diabetes and LTD Claims: What You Need To Know

The month of November is Diabetes Awareness Month and November 14, 2022 is World Diabetes Day. This is significant as it speaks to the impact Diabetes has worldwide and in Canada.

Topics covered in this blog will include:

  • What is Diabetes?
  • Important Facts/Statistics
  • How Diabetes Might Affect Your Ability to Work
  • What to Know When Making A Claim for Short-Term or Long-Term Disability Benefits
  • Reasons an Insurance Company Might Deny Your Claim

There are two main types of diabetes mellitus

Type 1 Diabetes 

​Type 1 diabetes occurs when the pancreas releases little to no insulin and the immune system attacks the cells that would process insulin, causing sugar to build up in the bloodstream instead of being used as energy. Type 1 diabetes usually develops in childhood/adolescence and is less common and is always treated with insulin.

Type 2 Diabetes

Type 2 diabetes, which usually develops as an adult and is more common, occurs when the body can’t properly use the insulin released or does not produce enough insulin. As with type 1 diabetes, what happens is sugar will build up in the blood instead of being used up as energy.


Unlike type 1 diabetes, type 2 diabetes does not always require insulin and medications if it has not reached a certain level of severity, can be treated with diet and exercise.

Gestational Diabetes 

Gestational diabetes is another type of diabetes, that affects pregnant women. It occurs during the 2nd or 3rd trimester of pregnancy. It occurs as a result of the body not being able to produce enough insulin to handle the effects of changing hormone levels and the growth of a baby at the same time.


Between 3-20% of pregnant women develop gestational diabetes and in most cases they did not have diabetes before their pregnancy. Usually the diabetes goes away after giving birth.

​

Doctors typically check for gestational diabetes through a blood test 24-48 weeks into pregnancy.

Important Facts & Statistics

These facts and statistics shed some light on the impact diabetes has worldwide.

According to the International Diabetes Federation Diabetes Atlas

  • 1 in 11 adults (aged 20-79 years) have diabetes, which totals 463 millions people
  • By the year 2030, the number of people with diabetes is expected to rise to 522 million
  • 3 out of 4 people diagnosed with diabetes live in low- and middle-income countries
  • 1 out of 2 people with diabetes remain undiagnosed (this equates to 232 million people)
  • Diabetes is a leading cause of heart disease, stroke, blindness, kidney failure and lower limb amputation
  • Diabetes cause 4.2 million deaths in 2019
  • 80% of type 2 diabetes are preventable through healthy lifestyle

According to Diabetes Canada

  • There are 11 million Canadians living with diabetes or pre-diabetes;
  • Every 3 minutes, someone in Canada is diagnosed with diabetes.

​According to the Government of Canada website

A 20 year diabetes surveillance study was conducted between 2009 and 2019 and found the following:

  • Between 2000 to 2016 the proportion of Canadians living with diabetes increased by an average of 3.3.% per year
  • There are 3.2 million Canadians are living with diabetes
  • 1 in 9 adults (aged 20 and older) live with diabetes
  • On average, 549 Canadians are diagnosed with diabetes every day (approx. 201,000 new cases each year)
  • Among Canadian adults (20 years +), 6.1% have pre-diabetes
  • Diabetes is more common among adult men than adult women
  • Women who develop gestational diabetes are at risk for developing type 2 diabetes later in life

Complications of Diabetes 

Different complications can arise from having diabetes, for various reasons and these complications may make it difficult to continue working, either at a physical type of job or a sedentary type of job.


These include:

  • Anxiety
  • Depression
  • Celiac Disease
  • Eating Disorders
  • Diabetic Retinopathy (can lead to blindness)
  • Heart Disease
  • High Blood Pressure
  • Chronic Kidney Disease
  • Diabetic Ketoacidosis
  • Stroke
  • Erectile Dysfunction
  • Diabetic Peripheral Neuropathy
  • Foot Problems (i.e. ulcers, infections, lead to amputations, osteomyelitis)


The complications that arise from diabetes can cause functional limitations and restrictions and significantly impact a your ability to perform daily activities including the essential duties of employment from a physical and psychological perspective.

Diabetes and Disability Claims

The application package for short-term disability and long-term disability benefits both contain an Employee Statement, an Attending Physician Statement and an Employer Statement.

The Employee Statement 

​When applying for disability benefits, it is important that you outline the ways that your condition affects all aspects of your life on this form. You have the opportunity to describe the onset of your symptoms, how they impact your daily live and your ability to work and overall functioning. You are able to provide information about your treatment providers/specialists and any treatment you are attending.

The Attending Physician Statement 

This form should be completed by the doctor who can best explain your condition to the insurance company. ​On this form, it is important that your doctor explain the nature of your condition and any complications that it causes. Your doctor should specify the nature of your condition, your diagnosis, your symptoms and any findings on examination/testing. Your doctor should also be specific when detailing your restrictions and limitations and how they relate to your own occupation and occupations you may be suited for.

Provide Clear Examples

On both the Employee Statement and Attending Physician Statement, clear examples of how your illness/condition affects your life and activities of daily living should be given.


For example:

  • If you work in a physical- labour type position and experience peripheral neuropathy (numbness in the legs or feet) or other types of foot problems, your limitations and restrictions could be difficulty walking, driving, or standing for long periods of time.
  • If you work in a sedentary type position, say working at a computer most of the day, and experience anxiety, depression, retinopathy or other eye issues your limitations and restrictions might be difficulty focusing and concentrating, difficulty seeing and focusing on the computer screen, or difficulty interacting with others.

Submit Supportive Medical Evidence 

Medical information that could be submitted with your application or in support of your claim could include bloodwork, x-rays that show if any deterioration has occurred, consultation reports from any specialists seen, hospital records and records from any dietician or diabetes education centre.

Seek Treatment 

As with any condition, the insurance company is looking to see if you are seeking appropriate treatment from the proper specialists or treatment providers (i.e. endocrinologist, internal medicine specialist, diabetes education centre). As well, the insurance company is looking for evidence that you seek regular treatment, on an ongoing basis.

Employer Statement

Your employer is required to complete an Employer Statement (also referred to as a Plan Sponsor Statement) which provides details such as your date of hire, last date worked and salary. Your employer can also provide details such as any observations made concerning your ability to do your job (i.e. the date when you were you no longer able to perform your job duties as of a certain date) or if you required modified duties or accommodations (of if they are available).

Reasons Your Claim Might Be Denied 

There are many reasons as to why your insurance company might decide to deny your claim for short-term or long-term disability benefits.


A few common examples are:

  • Your insurer does not feel that you are seeking treatment on a regular basis or are receiving appropriate treatment;
  • You are not under the care of an appropriate specialist in the opinion of the insurer;
  • Lack of objective medical evidence to support the severity of your symptoms;
  • There are no medically supported restrictions or limitations;
  • You can work in a sedentary position (if your own job was physical), or if your position was sedentary, you should be able to continue working in such a capacity;


If your claim has been denied at any stage, be it from the outset, while you’re on claim or at the change of definition, you can fight the insurer’s decision. You are not limited to the insurer’s internal appeal process as you have the option to start a lawsuit against them.

​

You should be sure to speak with a lawyer who is well-versed in short-term/long-term disability matters to find out what your rights and obligations are as an insured person and to make sure you do not miss any limitation periods. 

Our law firm offers a free initial consultation and our lawyers have helped many clients who have made disability claims related to diabetes and whose claims have been denied by their insurance companies.

Breast Cancer and Long-term Disability Claims

As many of you may know, October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month.


This blog post will discuss:

  • What is breast cancer
  • The impact of breast cancer
  • What some treatment complications and side effects are
  • Why a long-term disability claim might be denied for breast cancer
  • What to do if your disability claim has been denied

What is breast cancer?

There are different types of breast cancer . Ductal carcinoma is when breast cancer starts in the cells that line the ducts and lobular carcinoma which starts in the cells of lobules. Both these types of cancer can be either “in situ” which means they do not metastasize or they can be invasive. Less common types of breast cancer include inflammatory breast cancer, Paget disease and triple negative breast cancer.

The impact of breast cancer

The Statistics

  • Breast cancer affects 1 in 8 Canadian women
  • Men can also be diagnosed with breast cancer
  • The most recent statistics from 2022 estimate that 28,600 women and 270 men in Canada will receive a breast cancer diagnosis and almost 5,500 women and 55 men will die from this form of cancer
  • Breast cancer is the second leading cause of cancer deaths in Canadian women and it is expected to remain one of the four most diagnosed types of cancer

The Canadian Breast Cancer Foundation also tells us that…

  • 1 in 4 cancers diagnosed in Canadian women are breast cancer
  • Women aged 50 to 69 years of age are the age group most at risk for the development of breast cancer (51% of breast cancer diagnoses)
  • 17% of breast cancer diagnoses will be in women under the age of 50, with 13% occurring in women aged 40 to 49
  • The 5-year survival rate for breast cancer in Canada is 89%
  • Since 1987, breast cancer mortality rates have decreased by 44%

Treatment side effects/complications

Complications from cancer treatments unfortunately do occur, and your insurance company may not understand the extent of your limitations resulting from post-cancer difficulties. Sometimes, after undergoing chemotherapy and radiation therapy, cancer patients develop chemotherapy induced neuropathic pain, lymphedema, fibromyalgia and psychological conditions such as anxiety and depression .

Side effects and complications from breast cancer treatment , can include…

  • Lymphedema (swelling/discomfort in the arm that has persisted more than 6-12 weeks after surgery)
  • Edema (swelling), particularly near the breast area
  • Numbness, tenderness or skin sensitivity as a result of surgery or radiation
  • Fibrosis (thickening/scarring of connective tissue)
  • Pain and aching (also referred to as myalgias), that can start after surgery, chemotherapy or hormone therapy
  • Bone loss which increases the risk for osteoporosis and risk of fractures
  • Increased risk for heart problems as a result of radiation therapy, chemotherapy and targeted therapies
  • Ongoing fatigue, from both the physical and emotional effects of treatment
  • “Brain fog”- essentially mental fatigue, where you experience difficulties focusing, concentrating, forgetfulness because of treatment and stress
  • Sleep disturbances/insomnia related to stress or as a side effect of treatment

Breast cancer and long-term disability claims: Why would my claim be denied?

When someone makes a claim for long-term disability benefits as a result of a breast cancer diagnosis, the length of disability might extend beyond the duration of treatment.


You may have received benefits for the period you are receiving chemotherapy and radiation and recovering from surgeries but denied further benefits past that period.

Reasons why your insurance company may terminate your claim after treatment has finished could include: 

  • Your own occupation is sedentary, and you should have the ability to work in a sedentary position
  • You appear to have the ability to work in an alternative sedentary occupation (if your own occupation was a physical labour job)
  • You completed a rehabilitation program organized by your insurance company to prepare you for a return to work, therefore you should have the ability to work
  • You participated in a functional capacity evaluation which demonstrated your ability to work or did not reveal limitations or restrictions preventing you from returning to some form of work
  • No objective medical evidence is found in your doctors’ records or on testing
  • You have not had a recurrence of cancer and your symptoms are subjective (in the opinion of the insurance company)
  • Your cancer is in remission and you have a good prognosis (i.e. it has not metastasized)
  • No medical limitations or restrictions have been identified by the insurance company’s medical consultant

What can I do if my claim is denied?

You might receive a denial letter telling you that your insurance company feels there is a lack of medical evidence to account for your inability work.


But what happens when your oncologist tells you that you are in remission though you feel you are not able to return to work due to your ongoing pain, fatigue or other complications?


The reality may be that your treating physician(s) have advised you to remain off work and agree that you are unable to work.


You may be on the road to remission, but you could be struggling with pain, anxiety, depression and be on various medications to help you cope with your symptoms. Your medications (i.e. hormone replacement therapy) could be causing severe side effects. You may not have findings on diagnostic imaging but that does not mean you do not have symptoms that affect your day to day functioning.


It is important to demonstrate to your insurance company that you do have limitations and restrictions because of pain, anxiety, depression, brain fog, fibromyalgia or other symptoms you may be experiencing.


By continuing to see your treating physicians and reporting your symptoms, you will have documented how your symptoms affect your day to day activities and your ability to work. Showing that you consistently attend doctor’s appointments, participate in prescribed treatment and take medications as directed is also important as you need to demonstrate that you are actively seeking treatment and are under the care of a physician.


if your claim has been denied for any reason, do not hesitate to seek the advice of a disability lawyer. An experienced lawyer can help you to understand why your claim was denied and what your legal options are and advise you of any limitation periods. It is always important to know your rights as an insured person.

PTSD & Long-Term Disability Benefits

As long-term disability lawyers, we know there are various types of injuries and illnesses, be it physical, psychological, or a combination of both that can render a person unable to work. One such condition is post-traumatic stress disorder.

​This blog will discuss:

  • What is Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder?
  • What Are the Symptoms of PTSD?
  • How PTSD Might Affect Your Ability to Work
  • What to Know When Making a Claim for Disability Benefits
  • Reasons an Insurance Company Might Deny Your Claim
  • Why You Should Contact a Lawyer if Your Claim was Denied

What is Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder? 

Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a type of anxiety disorder that can develop after an individual has experienced, witnessed or been repeatedly exposed to a major trauma.


It is felt that certain types of professions including police officers, paramedics, firefighters and soldiers (collectively known as “first responders”) have higher rates of post-traumatic stress disorder compared to other professions.


PTSD is also a type of operational stress injury which is defined as any persistent psychological difficulty resulting from operational duties such as law enforcement, combat or any other service related duties. People who experience high levels of operational stress injury are at a greater risk of developing depression, anxiety or PSTD.


First responders are not the only group of people who are susceptible to PTSD. As PTSD is a response to traumatic life events, victims of car accidents, fires, violent crimes, workplace stress or bullying or who have witnessed a family member or friend or another person harmed or killed can develop PTSD.


Examples of trauma given by Anxiety Canada include exposure to:

  • Actual or threatened death (i.e. war, a serious car accident, witnessed a murder)
  • Serious injury (i.e. severe burns, extensive hospitalizations)
  • Sexual violence


It is explained that exposure can mean:

  • Directly experiencing the event
  • Witnessed the event as it happens to others (i.e. a kidnapping)
  • Learning that the trauma occurred to a close family member or close friend (note that actual or threatened death must have been violent or accidental for example witnessed a friend die in a car accident)
  • Experiencing repeated or extreme exposure to aversive details of the event (for example, police offices being repeatedly exposed to victims of violent murders)


Not everyone who experiences a traumatic event will develop PTSD but many factors play a part in whether or not someone will develop the disorder. According to the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, factors like having experienced previous trauma, having a history of mental illness or post-traumatic stress disorder, having little or no social support after the traumatic event or experiencing other stressors after the event increase a person’s risk of developing PTSD.

What Are the Symptoms of PTSD? 

According to the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health , symptoms of PTSD can include:

  • Relieving the event/re-experiencing the event over and over again
  • Avoiding reminders of the event/the scene of the event
  • Fear that something bad is going to happen
  • Constant worrying
  • Recurrent nightmares
  • Avoidant behaviours (staying away from activities, people, places that remind you of the event)
  • Difficulty getting along with people
  • Loss of interest in activities you used to enjoy
  • Difficulty with feelings of love and pleasure
  • Difficulty concentrating
  • Easily angered
  • Difficulty sleeping (falling asleep & remaining asleep)
  • Sudden attacks of dizziness, fast heartbeat or shortness of breath
  • Fear of dying

appears to be an empty link with target https://www.ontario.ca/page/2019-novel-coronavirus

How PTSD Might Affect Your Ability to Work 

The symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder can be debilitating and cause significant functional impairments. PTSD affects your ability to sleep, focus and concentrate, ability to interact with others, ability to focus and concentrate, ability to participate in society and to function in general.


When sleep is impaired, the ability to focus and concentrate is impaired and memory is affected. Some people become severely depressed and anxious, and some people may develop physical symptoms.


Symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder can impact your ability to perform physical work, safety sensitive work and sedentary work.

What to know When Making a Claim for Disability Benefits 

Mental illnesses like post-traumatic stress disorder are often misunderstood by insurance companies.


PTSD falls into the category of illnesses/conditions that are often described as “invisible illnesses” or “invisible disabilities (think mental illnesses, fibromyalgia and chronic pain conditions). This is because objective tests like x-rays and bloodwork cannot confirm your diagnosis or provide proof of/an explanation for all of your symptoms, making it a challenge to prove your inability to work to your insurer.


If you have PTSD and are applying for short-term or long-term disability benefits, you should document how your treatment is going with your doctor, specialist or therapist and follow the treatment recommendations. Even if your claim is denied, it is always important to continue your treatment. These are important steps for your claim.

Reasons an Insurance Company Might Deny Your Claim 

You may receive a letter from your insurance company telling you your application has been denied or your benefits are being terminated for one or more of the following reasons:

  • No medical information has been received
  • Medical information was not submitted in time/by the deadline provided
  • You are not receiving appropriate treatment or being treated by the appropriate doctors or specialists in the insurer’s opinion
  • You should be able to work while continuing your treatment/receiving treatment would not interfere with your ability to work
  • There are no medically supported restrictions or limitations
  • You are outside of the “maximum recovery guidelines” according to the insurance company’s medical consultant
  • You have a pre-existing medical condition relating to your disability or causing your disability and you have been insured for less than 1 year under the group plan
  • You should be able to work in a sedentary position (if your own occupation is physical in nature)
  • You do not have the ability to work in your own occupation, but you should be able to work in an alternate occupation and you are now in the any occupation period
  • You did not participate in a rehabilitation program or gradual return to work program that was arranged for you and the insurer feels medical evidence does not explain why you are unable to participate

What You can do if Your Claim is Denied

Receiving a denial letter can be upsetting and frustrating. The terminology used in the letter may be unfamiliar to you and you may want clarification as to what certain terms mean and what your next steps should be.


Your insurance company gives you the option to appeal their decision through their own internal process (you can usually have up to 3 chances to appeal). You might go through all levels of appeal and not achieve the result you desire.


An experienced disability lawyer can help you understand what your rights are and what your options are. You can retain a lawyer as soon as you receive a denial letter and commence a court action. You do not have to wait to exhaust all appeal levels before you hire a lawyer and commence a lawsuit. Your lawyer can start a lawsuit and get your case into the court system as soon as possible.

COVID-19 and Short-Term Disability Claims

On March 17, 2020 the Government of Ontario enacted an order declaring an emergency under the Emergency Management and Civil Procedures Act to try to prevent further spread of the novel coronavirus and to protect the health and safety of its citizens. The order has been extended multiple times.

What is Short-Term Disability Insurance? 

Short-term disability (STD) benefits are meant to provide you with income replacement for a fixed period of time. Usually there is a short waiting period before benefits begin (i.e. 1 or 2 days). STD benefits can be paid anywhere from 15 to 26 weeks on average, depending on your policy. Most policies typically pay between 55-75% of weekly earnings.

What is COVID-19? 

COVID-19 is a coronavirus, which is a large family of viruses that causes illnesses ranging from the common cold to more serious respiratory infections like bronchitis, pneumonia or severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS). COVID-19 is a novel coronavirus which was not previous seen in humans before.


Currently, there are no specific treatments or vaccine to protect against coronaviruses.


Coronavirus has been added as a designated disease reportable under Ontario’s public health legislation.

Who is Most at Risk? 

The current risk to Canadians for contracting COVID-19 is considered high.


The symptoms of the coronavirus can be mild to severe. People who are at risk for severe cases include those with weaker immune systems and with chronic diseases such as diabetes, cancer, heart, renal or chronic lung disease. Complications from COVID-19 can lead to serious conditions like pneumonia, kidney failure (and in some cases, death).


Employees who are particularly vulnerable to contracting COVID-19 due to pre-existing disabilities, illnesses or conditions may be feeling distressed about the virus due to their higher risk of contracting the virus.


Someone who contracts the virus may experience a prolonged recovery and require an extended period of time off work.


​Those who experience mental health conditions such as anxiety disorders may also be experiencing exacerbations of their symptoms. First responders/front line responders and medical/health care workers may be experiencing increased stress, traumatic stress, overwhelm and other psychological symptoms during this time.

Applying for STD Benefits 

Employees who contract COVID-19 or are affected by it may be eligible to claim benefits under a salary continuance/short-term disability (STD) benefits plan.

Obtain a copy of your policy (if you can) 

If you don’t already have a copy of your benefits booklet or STD policy, or access to it, you should request it so you can be familiar with the terms of your policy and know who the key contacts are and what is required on your part in the event of a claim.

What are salary continuance/STD benefits? 

Salary continuance/STD plans are meant to provide income replacement for a time-limited period during illness or injury and benefits can last anywhere from 15 to 52 weeks.

What does “salary continuance” mean? 

Under a salary continuance plan, your employer continues to pay you if the insurer advises them you meet the test for totally disabled under the policy, this is known as an “administrative services only” policy.

Is there a waiting period? 

There may be a short waiting period before benefits start, depending on your policy which can be 1 day or 1 week. Some policies waive the waiting period for hospitalizations or certain illnesses.

How are benefits calculated? 

Benefits are based on a percentage of your weekly earnings (can be from 50% to even 100% of weekly earnings) and are usually taxable.

How do I apply? 

The application package typically consists of 3 documents; the Employee/Member Statement, the Attending Physician’s Statement and the Employer/Plan Sponsor Statement.

You are responsible for making sure an application is submitted within the required timelines (if possible).

The Employee Statement is the document you are required to complete and is where you can indicate the nature of your illness/injuries and why you are unable to work, in your own words.

The Attending Physician’s Statement should be completed by your primary treatment provider and is where your doctor provides medical evidence of your inability to work and may also include clinical notes and records to support your application.

The Employer Statement is required by the insurance company in order to calculate your benefits.

What if My Claim is Denied? 

​A denial of benefits can occur at any stage of the claim, whether at the initial application or while you are on claim. You can appeal the insurer’s decision through their internal process however you do have the right to retain a lawyer to commence a legal action against them.


If your claim for salary continuance benefits or short-term disability benefits has been denied, it is important to seek legal advice so you can be aware of any limitation periods (deadlines to commence a lawsuit) and be informed of your rights.

Migraines and Long-Term Disability Benefits

People make claims for long-term disability for various types of physical injuries or physical or psychological illnesses including migraines.

This blog post will discuss:

  • What is a Migraine?
  • What Causes a Migraine?
  • How Are Migraines Treated?
  • Important Facts/Statistics
  • How a Migraine Condition Might Affect Your Ability to Work
  • What to Know When Making a Claim for Short-Term or Long-Term Disability Benefits
  • Reasons an Insurance Company Might Deny Your Claim

What is a Migraine? 

A migraine is a type of headache disorder. Headache disorders include migraines, tension-type headaches and cluster headaches.

A migraine disorder most commonly affects those between the ages of 35 to 45 and is more common in women due to hormonal influences. It is recurrent, can be life-long and is characterized by recurring attacks which include a moderate to severe headache that is one-sided, pulsating, aggravated by routine physical activity and lasts from hours to 2-3 days. Migraines are also associated with nausea and attack frequency can be between once a week to once a year.

Migraines can also be associated with other conditions such as temporomandibular joint dysfunction.

Migraines can occur with or without aura . Migraine with aura is when a person experiences some nervous system symptoms such as visual, sensory, movement or speech disturbances. For example, you may feel muscle weakness or have a sensation that someone is touching you. Most people experience migraines without aura. Some people also experience sensitivity to light (photophobia), to sound (phonophobia), smells and touch, nausea and vomiting, light-headedness, possible fainting and blurred vision.


It is felt that both genetics and environment play a role in the development of migraines. The frequency with which migraines occur differs from person to person.

What Can Cause a Migraine? 

A migraine can be triggered by a number of factors which range from:

  • Hormonal changes (including hormonal medications i.e. oral contraceptives/hormone replacement therapy)
  • Foods and food additives (i.e. aged cheeses, salty foods, processed foods, aspartame, MSG)
  • Alcoholic or overly caffeinated beverages
  • Changes in sleep-wake patterns (e.g. jet lag)
  • Weather changes/change in barometric pressure
  • Physical factors (e.g. intense physical exertion)
  • Emotional factors (stress, depression, anxiety)
  • Sensory stimuli – something that stimulates your senses to the extreme such as bright lights, the glare of the sun, loud sounds, strong smells
  • Medications

How are Migraines Treated? 

Treatments for migraines include pain relieving medications and preventative medications, but they may not do away with migraines completely. They may help decrease the frequency and duration of migraines. In general, the goal of treatment is to prevent a full-blown migraine attack. Botox injections are also a form of treatment offered to people with migraines.


It is also recommended that you avoid known migraine triggers (once you determine what they are). Some doctors recommend keeping a headache journal to be able to identify triggers so you can see if there were any noticeable signs leading up to a migraine attack.

As well, another suggestion that is made by the International Headache Society is the “5-4-3-2-1” criteria used to diagnose migraines without aura.


​This is explained as:

  • 5 or more attacks lasting anywhere from 4 hours to 3 days
  • At minimum, experiencing 2 of the following: pain occurring on one side of the head, with a pulsating quality, moderate to severe pain and it is aggravated by routine physical activity
  • At least one additional symptom i.e. sensitivity to light, sensitivity to sound or nausea or vomiting

Important Facts/Statistics 

According to the World Health Organization ,

  • Headache disorders are among the most common disorders of the nervous system and they are underestimated, under-recognized and under-treated worldwide.
  • 1.7-4% of the world’s adult population report experiencing headache 15+ days per month.
  • Migraine was found to be the 6th leading cause of disability in 2013 worldwide and headache disorders collectively the 3rd highest in the Global Burden of Disease Study.


According to The Migraine Trust ,

  • Migraine is more prevalent than diabetes, epilepsy and asthma combined.
  • Migraines affect 1 in 7 people globally.
  • Chronic migraine affects 2% of the world’s population.
  • Migraine affects 3x as many women as men.
  • More than 75% of migraineurs experience at least 1 attack per month and more than 50% experience severe impairment during migraine attacks.

How Migraines Affect Your Ability to Work 

It is apparent that the symptoms of a migraine can be debilitating and can limit a person’s daily activities both physically and mentally. A migraine can interfere with a person’s ability to do both sedentary and physical work as it is painful and interferes with a person’s ability to focus, and is worsened by bright lights and loud noises.

​

As well, the long-term effort of coping with chronic migraine can predispose someone to other illnesses. It is felt that anxiety and depression are significantly more common in migraine sufferers.

What to Know When Making a Claim for Disability Benefits 

The Employee Statement/Plan Member Statement 

This document asks for your account of why you stopped working. You can provide information about your symptom frequency and duration, your functional limitations and your restrictions and how your medical condition affects your ability to function on a day to day basis.

​

You should be specific as to how your condition affects your ability to perform your job functions.

The Attending Physician’s Statement 

Your doctor should outline your limitations and restrictions, your symptoms, any observable clinical findings and provide relevant records. It is important that your doctor explain how your condition impacts your ability to perform your job and what your prognosis is.

Submit Supportive Medical Evidence 

The insurance company is looking for information that speaks to how long you could be off work for and that supports your limitations and restrictions.

​

With conditions like headache disorders, “objective” medical evidence may be hard to provide so it is important that your doctor/treatment providers provide as much detail as possible when it comes to your symptoms and functional limitations.

Seek Appropriate Treatment 

Depending on what your condition is, you may or may not require a referral to a specialist. Migraines are considered a neurological disorder and your family physician might refer you to a neurologist to confirm a diagnosis and treatment plan.


You may be prescribed medications and the insurance company will want to know if you are taking medications as prescribed.

​

If other treatments such as cognitive behavioural therapy, psychotherapy or physiotherapy are recommended, the insurance company will want to know if you are adhering to the recommended treatment schedule

Reasons Why Your Claim Might be Denied 

A claim may be denied for a number of reasons. The denial could be for medical or non-medical reasons.


A few examples of reasons for denial include:

  • Medical information has not been submitted by your doctor;
  • The deadline to submit further medical information has passed;
  • You have a pre-existing condition and you have been insured for less than 1 year;
  • The insurance company does not feel you are receiving appropriate treatment or being treated by the appropriate doctors/specialists;
  • The insurance company feels you should be able to attend treatment and continue working and that receiving treatment would not interfere with your ability to work;
  • There are no medically supported restrictions or limitations;
  • You are outside the “maximum guidelines” for recovery according to their medical consultant.

If your short-term or long-term disability claim has been denied at any stage, you should know you can fight the insurance company’s decision. If you have appealed and appealed and been denied, you do have the option to start a lawsuit against the insurance company, subject to what is known as a limitation period. It is important to contact a lawyer as soon as possible to find out what your rights are.

Bad Faith and Long-Term Disability Claims

You may have heard of the term bad faith as it relates to insurance claims and wonder what it means.

​

This blog post will take a look at what bad faith means when it comes to long-term disability (LTD) claims.

What are Bad Faith Claims? 

Bad faith claims are claims that arise when an insurance company has grossly mishandled the claim of its insured (the policy member; whether under a group or private policy).

​

Examples of bad faith are:

  • Not rendering a decision about benefits in a timely fashion, even though medical information shows that the insured is totally disabled.
  • Denial of benefits without medical certification indicating the insured is able to resume regular occupation.
  • Unreasonable interpretation of policy.

What is the Duty of Good Faith? 

In Canada, the courts tell us that the duty of good faith requires that an insurer act both promptly and fairly when assessing claims.


Breaching the duty of good faith in an insurance claim can lead to what is known as punitive damages.


In order for the court to find that unfair conduct has taken place, and to award punitive damages, the court must find that the insurer acted unfairly and ‘delinquently’.


The idea is to reveal how the claim was handled from the outset and by what means the insurer actually arrived at the decision to stop payment or deny the claim.

Bad faith claims are meant to act as a deterrent so that insurers will not exploit the vulnerability of the insured.


Morrison J., in Asseltine v. Manufacturers Life Insurance Company (Plaintiff sues disability insurer) said:


“A duty of good faith and fair dealing requires an even-handed evaluation of all evidence before the insurer by the insurer. Just as one cannot cherry pick the information to send to an assessor for a rehabilitation opinion, one cannot choose only to accept certain medical evidence in the face of compelling conflicting evidence.”

How Does It Work? 

​In addition to the duty of acting in good faith, the insurer has other duties to consider. The following list is not an exhaustive list.

Duty to Assess the Evidence in a Balanced and Reasonable Manner 

The insurer should assess the merits of the claim in a balanced and reasonable manner. The insurer cannot dismiss credible, alternative evidence that does not support its pre-conceived ideas.

Duty to Reasonably Interpret the Policy 

The policy language must be reviewed and checked; the policy should actually be read.

Duty to Adequately Investigate 

A timely and thorough investigation of the claim should be made before a claim is denied, this is essential where a claim for disability is being made under a long-term disability policy. Medical investigations are to be made and all reports are to be considered, from the insured person’s doctors as well.

Duty to Inform 

The insurer has to inform the insured person of the nature and extent of the benefits that are payable to him/her, and assist the insured in the completion of the necessary documentation (provide instructions).


When an insurer decides to deny a claim, there is a duty to properly inform that the denial has been made, the insured person should not be told or misled by stating “the matter is under investigation”.


In a lot of cases, we do see that insurance companies write to our clients and postpone the actual denial of benefits by saying that a final decision has not been made, the matter is under investigation pending further documentation etc. This is incredibly frustrating to our clients!

Duty not to misinform 

For example, not providing a copy of the actual policy.

Duty not to Take Advantage of an Insured’s Economic Vulnerability 

For example, by trying to get the insured person to settle at an early stage in the claim, for a lesser amount than the claim is worth due to their financial situation.

What are the Duties of the Insured?

The insured person, as this is a contractual relationship has duties as well, to act in “good faith”.

Duty to be Honest 

For example, in any type of disability policy, to disclose all relevant health information, all employment details, all previous claims, details of any WSIB claims or other sources of income, anything that may be relevant. You do not want the insurance company to find out information about you in any way except from you yourself.

Duty to Rehabilitate and Mitigate 

You have the duty to attend rehabilitation (physiotherapy, massage, psychotherapy, etc.), whatever type of therapy that helps you try to feel better and has been medically recommended. You must actively be under the care of a physician and actively be trying to get better.


Mitigation refers to the attempt to return to work. If you do try to return to work or to volunteer you must advise the insurance company of your attempts, even if unsuccessful.

Duty to Give Notice of a Claim in a Timely Manner 

If you are seriously injured or suffering from an illness that takes you off work and believe you qualify for long-term disability benefits, you should apply as soon as possible. Your policy will tell you how long you have to apply for LTD benefits after you first became disabled.


You should consider submitting your application within this timeframe as one reason insurers do tend to deny claims is for late applications.


You should also consider that in order to qualify for long-term disability benefits, you have to be continuously disabled throughout the qualifying period, which can be anywhere from 15 to 52 weeks. You should apply for benefits before the end of the qualifying period as it will take time for your claim to be processed, especially if further information is needed.

How does Your Lawyer Help?

Starting the Lawsuit 

When your benefits are denied or terminated, you have the right to hire a lawyer to fight the denial of your claim. Once we have been retained and have the appropriate details (policy number, claim number, date of disability, date of denial), we commence a court action against the disability insurer. The action is commenced by issuing a documented called a Statement of Claim. This is the document that officially starts the legal process.

​

In the Statement of Claim, your lawyer outlines what it is you are suing for. When suing an LTD insurer, we include a section where we plead that the insurer has adjudicated the claim in bad faith. In order to make a claim for bad faith, we must explicitly include it in this document so that the insurance company knows this type of claim is being brought.

Exchanging Documents 

During the course of your lawsuit, documents will be exchanged with the other party, so that the lawyer for the insurer can have a chance to review new medical information and other important information relating to your disability and inability to work.

​

The insurance company will provide your lawyer with a copy of their policy and claims file and your lawyer has a chance to review these documents and see what went on during the course of your claim and how the insurer came to the decision to deny your claim.

Negotiating a Fair Settlement 

After lawyers have been appointment and documents have been exchanged, lawyers will discuss next steps and how to best proceed to resolve the case.


Whether through settlement talks at a settlement conference or exchanging offers by way of a written settlement proposal or at a private mediation, your lawyer represents your interests and will negotiate a fair and just settlement for you.


Your lawyer considers the amount of benefits owed to you since your claim has been denied (past) and how many years left in your policy when negotiating a settlement (future benefits). Your lawyer will not present any offer to the insurance company without your knowledge and approval.

Your lawyer also has to make sure you are aware of any offers or counter-offers made on behalf of the insurance company.


Your lawyer is there to advise you on the fairness of any offers made to you.


You should be aware that the final decision to accept or reject an offer to settle is yours to make.

We hope that this overview of bad faith claims and insurers duties to you has been helpful.

Secret Link