Life Insurance and Mental Health: How Claims Are Assessed and Challenged

A life insurance lawyer assists a client in filling out insurance paperwork, guiding him through the challenges of mental health claims.

When filing a claim for someone that has passed, many people are surprised to learn that mental health conditions can affect the outcome when a claim is made after a loved one's death.


Insurance companies may have the legal right to assess your mental and physical health history when you apply for life insurance. In some cases, an insurer may deny your application based on your medical history.


This blog explains how some insurers assess mental health in life insurance claims and some common challenges applicants and families may face and how working with a life insurance lawyer can help you navigate a difficult situation.


If your life insurance claim has been denied, you are not without options. A life insurance lawyer can help you understand whether the denial was handled fairly and what steps may be available to you.

What Are the Disclosure Requirements When Applying for Life Insurance?

Life insurance applications typically include detailed health questionnaires. You are required to answer these truthfully, including any history of mental health conditions and any related medications or treatments.


If you answer inaccurately or omit information the insurer may later argue that you misrepresented your health. This is one of the most common reasons claims are denied after a policyholder's death. Honesty on your application protects both you and your family.

What If a Claim Is Denied?

If a claim has been denied following a death by suicide, it is worth speaking with a lawyer who is experienced in dealing with life insurance claims. A denial is not always the final word. A lawyer can review the circumstances, assess whether the denial was valid and advise you on the options available.

Common Challenges in Mental Health-Related Life Insurance Claims

Even when a policy is in force, families can face obstacles when making a claim involving mental illness. Common challenges include:

1. Misrepresentation Allegations

If an insurer believes the policyholder did not fully disclose their mental health history on their application, the insurer may assert that the policy is void. Whether that allegation is valid and how to respond depends on the specific facts of your situation and on the advice you are given by a lawyer.

2. Insurer Skepticism

Unfortunately, stigma around mental health can still affect how some claims are handled. Families dealing with a mental health-related death may feel they are being treated unfairly or that the insurer is unfairly evaluating the claim. If you have questions regarding a denied life insurance claim, you have the right to speak with a lawyer to explain your rights.

A man feels stressed as he reviews a denied claim, illustrating how a life insurance lawyer can help navigate challenges.

How a Life Insurance Lawyer Can Help

If a claim has been denied, a life insurance claim lawyer can help you understand your rights and help you take meaningful action. This may include:

  • Reviewing the denial letter to assess whether the insurer’s reason is legally valid
  • Gathering medical evidence to support the claim or challenge the insurer’s position
  • Responding to misrepresentation allegations and/or fraudulent misrepresentation allegations by demonstrating that the application was completed honestly and in good faith
  • Advising on your options if the insurer refuses to pay


There may be time limits that apply for claiming life insurance benefits and there are time limits to challenge a denied life insurance claim. If you are considering challenging a denial, it is important to seek out legal advice as soon as possible.

How Can Aaron Waxman and Associates, P.C. Help?

We understand how devastating it is to lose a loved one and how much harder that loss becomes when a life insurance claim is denied. Our team is here to help you understand your legal rights and pursue the benefits your family may be entitled to.


At Aaron Waxman and Associates, P.C., we provide:

  • Careful review of denial letters and policy language
  • Guidance on disclosure requirements and pre-existing condition clauses
  • Advocacy against unfair treatment in mental health-related claims
  • Clear, honest advice on the realistic options available to you


We work on a no upfront fees basis, which means you can speak with us without financial pressure. Our goal is to ensure you receive fair treatment and the support you deserve during a very difficult time.

A life insurance lawyer meets with a couple on appealing a denied claim to help protect their rights.

Conclusion

Mental health is one factor that can unfairly impact a life insurance claim. Notwithstanding, a denied life insurance claim is not always the end of the road.


If a life insurance claim has been denied, understanding your legal rights is the first step. With the support of an experienced life insurance lawyer, you can assess your options and take action.


Has your life insurance claim been denied? You don't have to face the insurance company alone. Contact Aaron Waxman and Associates, P.C. today for a free consultation with a life insurance lawyer.

We offer a free initial consultation that can be arranged at a date and time of your choosing and at your convenience.

Recent posts from our Knowledge Centre

By Dev Ops July 23, 2026
Learn how the change of definition in your long-term disability policy affects your benefits and how a long-term disability lawyer can help you protect your rights.
The outside entrance of an apartment building depicts a wet pavement, posing a risk of an injury fro
By Dev Ops November 18, 2025
Learn who is liable for slip and falls in apartment buildings, landlord vs. tenant responsibility and when you should pursue a slip and fall injury lawsuit.
 A concerned man sitting at his desk reviews a letter.
By Dev Ops November 4, 2025
If your LTD benefits are terminated and you are not ready to return to work, learn common reasons, steps to follow and how a long-term disability lawyer can help.
A grieving woman sitting on the couch reviews a life insurance denial letter.
October 28, 2025
Confused by a life insurance claim denial? Learn what the contestability period means for beneficiaries and how a life insurance lawyer can protect your rights.
Show More
By Dev Ops July 23, 2026
Learn how the change of definition in your long-term disability policy affects your benefits and how a long-term disability lawyer can help you protect your rights.
The outside entrance of an apartment building depicts a wet pavement, posing a risk of an injury fro
By Dev Ops November 18, 2025
Learn who is liable for slip and falls in apartment buildings, landlord vs. tenant responsibility and when you should pursue a slip and fall injury lawsuit.
 A concerned man sitting at his desk reviews a letter.
By Dev Ops November 4, 2025
If your LTD benefits are terminated and you are not ready to return to work, learn common reasons, steps to follow and how a long-term disability lawyer can help.
A grieving woman sitting on the couch reviews a life insurance denial letter.
October 28, 2025
Confused by a life insurance claim denial? Learn what the contestability period means for beneficiaries and how a life insurance lawyer can protect your rights.
top 100 canada law blog award
  • This blog is for informational purposes only and is not meant to substitute legal advice. Please read our disclaimer for further information.
  • All of our lawyers are licensed by The Law Society of Upper Canada
  • Office in Toronto and able to represent people in the province of Ontario